What you should know.


When I started building this piece of software I (we) thought about what
kind of license would be suitable for this webapplication. Bearing in
mind that all the applications we needed to build this web-application
are licensed with Open Source / Free Software in mind we decided to
licence it with the:

GNU GENERAL PUBLIC LICENSE Version 2, June 1991.

January 2001 I visited the expo in Amsterdam. One of the keynote
speakers was Richard Stallman. I think we all know him from his
publications on the web. He is a true beleiver when it comes to 'Free
Software', next to that he is working very hard to make sure that the
patent issues are getting enough attention. 

After the talk he gave on the Linux Expo in Amsterdam, Jan 2001, I had a
small discussion with both Cor Gest Jr. and Patrick van Zweden. Patrick
mentioned that we might want to see if the phpreview idea could be
patented if all goes down the drain in the European parlement (patent
issues).

This made me write Richard Stallman on this issue. He pointed out some
of the issues regarding patenting. He also asked me what kind of reviews
we are showing. I told him that we are showing reviews on all kinds of
Linux / Open Source related books, yes he pointed out that we should use
'Free Software' instead of Open Source. These reviews are located on the
site of the Dutch Linux Community, http://nl.linux.org/boeken/ . We are
planning to show some of the English reviews on the same books at the
phpReview site, http://phpReview.nl.linux.org/

Richard Stallman tried to convince me that we should only review Free
Manual / Books since it would undermine the campaign to encourage people
to insist on free manuals if we would allow non-free Manuals / Books
too.

Let me clear things out a little, Richard Stallman was kind enough to
explain it to me.

Free doesn't mean that it's not commercial. Free means that you have the
right to use the information of the printed Manuals / Books for other
purposes then just reading it.  You are, in most cases, allowed to
publish and change it as long as you provide the information to the
original writers of this information. 

More details on these licenses can be found at the following url:

http://www.fsf.org/philosophy/license-list.html#DocumentationLicenses

Since we, the NLO-boek team, also allow reviews of non-free Books I
decided you should know why we are doing this. As the main author of
phpReview I think that all information, both free and non-free, should
be looked at. Knowledge is the greatest freedom you can find on this
planet. If we give people a chance to know what kind of information is
available and provide them the thought of the reviewer about this
information, people will have the benefit of knowing what others think
about these books. 

phpReview is build with this kind of information in mind. Withdrawing
information, even if it's non-free, would set us back in years,
politically spoken, and could even make us wonder ourselves if 'Big
brother' is watching us. "You shall not publish non-free information".

Reading this you might wonder you why we didn't choose another license.
I must tell you it did cross my mind. The reason I didn't even think of
it is that we would like to make sure that phpReview will have the
chance to grow into a tool that will allow you to provide all
information you want. We do, however, think that all users/developers
should benefit from the code you might want to add/alter. It will give
both them and you the freedom to use a tool which can provide
information to your visitor, both 'Free' and 'Non Free'.

Hans Wolters, Feb. 6, 2001.

